Does Frank Thomas belong in the Hall of Fame?

[The Mailman]

With the retirement announcement of Frank Thomas in the media, many are putting in their two cents worth regarding whether he's a hall of fame candidate or not since he spent most of his career as a DH. Personally, I think that thought is a joke. He was one of the most feared hitters of the 1990's.

Check out our take and feel free to post yours in this thread as well.

[akatdrake]

Being a Twins fan, he was always feared by our team, and I always held my breath with him at bat. I was surprised to see he was only a five-time all-star during his 19(?)-year career.

[Stifler's Mom]

I think he hurt his image and/or made people forget how good he once was by playing at least 5 years too long and that may hinder his chances.

[jws83]

500+ hrs, .300+ lifetime batting average... never linked to steroids... my fave player growing up.. it'd be a sin for him not to be a first ballot HOF