Cavaliers vs Thunder Rematch: NBA Odds and Prediction

by | Nov 4, 2026 | NBA Picks

Cleveland Cavaliers and Oklahoma City Thunder jerseys facing off on the court at Paycom Center in Oklahoma City at night

Cleveland Cavaliers at Oklahoma City Thunder
Wednesday, November 4, 2026
8:00 PM ET, Paycom Center

The Thunder are 2.5-point favorites over the Cavaliers at most books, with the total at 227.5. My play is Cavaliers +2.5.

Shai Gilgeous-Alexander took 35 shots on Monday night. Thirty-five. He made 14, hit 11 of 12 free throws, scored a season-high 43 and buried the go-ahead three with 32.6 seconds left as Oklahoma City escaped Cleveland with a 117-112 win. Two nights later, the same teams run it back in Oklahoma City, and the market has the Thunder as a small favorite again. I think it’s leaning on the wrong lesson.

One superstar can’t carry this load every night

That Monday box score was a warning sign for the Thunder, not a blueprint. Oklahoma City has been reeling since losing three starters to long-term injuries. Chet Holmgren (knee), Jalen Williams (ankle surgery) and Cason Wallace (shoulder surgery) are all on tonight’s injury report as out, and Jaylin Williams is questionable with back spasms. Before Monday, the Thunder had dropped two straight road games to Dallas and Houston by 24 and 21 points.

The numbers say the same thing. OKC ranks 22nd in offensive efficiency at 110.8 points per 100 possessions and is basically a break-even team (+0.3 per 100). Cleveland scores 117.0 per 100, seventh in the league, and is outscoring opponents by 3.5. Ajay Mitchell (20 points Monday) and Isaiah Hartenstein (14 rebounds) are good players. But when the offense is SGA or bust, one cold shooting night turns a close game into a loss.

The BEST 2026 Basketball Bonus: Deposit $100 to $1000 and get a 75% real cash bonus when you deposit using Bitcoin at Bovada Sportsbook!

Cleveland didn’t play poorly Monday. It committed just seven turnovers, went 9-of-17 from three in the third quarter to claw back from 14 down, and the fourth quarter had eight ties and eight lead changes. Donovan Mitchell had 17 points and 11 assists, Evan Mobley added 16, and rookie Meleek Thomas scored 17 in his first NBA start. James Harden (6.3 assists per game) gives the Cavs a second creator the Thunder simply don’t have right now. Cleveland is missing Jaylon Tyson (ankle) and Peyton Watson (hamstring), but nothing close to what Oklahoma City is dealing with.

The case for the Thunder

Here’s where I could get burned. Oklahoma City is 3-0 at home, and it won 64 games a year ago. The defense-first identity hasn’t vanished with the roster this thin; OKC still allows just 110.5 points per 100 possessions. The Thunder also beat Cleveland up on the glass Monday, 54-46, and the Cavs are only 1-2 on the road. If Gilgeous-Alexander gets to the line 12 times again and Hartenstein owns the boards, this number could be too short.

But I’m getting points with the more complete team in a matchup that went down to the final minute two nights ago. A last-shot game is the most likely outcome again, and I want the side with the cushion and the deeper bag of answers.

Projected score: Cavaliers 115, Thunder 113

The Pick: Cavaliers +2.5

Grab the points with Cleveland in the rematch and bring some extra bankroll into Wednesday night. New players at MyBookie Sportsbook get a 100% REAL CASH bonus on a first deposit of $100 to $300 with promo code PREDICT100. That’s a FREE way to bet Cavaliers +2.5 and the rest of your Wednesday NBA picks.

75% Cash up to $750 (With BTC)

Bovada