Dolphins at Bills NFL Picks: Week 11 Odds Before Thanksgiving Night

by | Nov 18, 2026 | nfl

Miami Dolphins and Buffalo Bills helmets facing off at midfield of Highmark Stadium in Orchard Park on a gray afternoon

Miami Dolphins at Buffalo Bills
Sunday, November 22, 2026
1:00 PM ET, Highmark Stadium

The Bills are 16.5-point favorites at most books, with the total at 45.5. My play is Dolphins +16.5.

Nobody wants to bet on a 1-8 team. That’s the whole point of a 16.5-point spread, the biggest of this NFL season, per Pro Football Talk. But this number asks Buffalo to do something it hasn’t done much this year, in a week when its mind will be on somebody else.

Buffalo doesn’t usually win this big

The Bills are 8-1 for the first time since 1991, and Joe Brady just joined Jim Caldwell and Herman Edwards as the only NFL coaches to win their first five road games in their first season. Josh Allen just passed Peyton Manning for the most touchdowns through a player’s first 10 seasons, and James Cook (971 rushing yards) ran for 157 against the Jets. Buffalo is very good.

Look at how it’s been winning, though. Five of the Bills’ eight wins came by 10 points or fewer, including a 37-34 overtime win against the Rams and a 33-30 escape in Las Vegas. They’ve cleared 16.5 only three times: 36-10 over Baltimore, 23-6 at Minnesota and 31-12 over the Jets last week. Allen himself said after the Jets game, “we’re not playing our best football right now.”

Then there’s the calendar. Buffalo hosts Kansas City on Thanksgiving night, four days after this game, in a matchup with big No. 1 seed implications. If the Bills are up 20 at halftime, I’d expect Allen to be in a baseball cap by the middle of the fourth quarter.

The BEST 2026 Football Bonus: Deposit $100 to $1000 and get a 75% real cash bonus when you deposit using Bitcoin at Bovada Sportsbook!

Miami loses, but it loses close

The Dolphins are banged up and bad. Malik Willis is on injured reserve with a groin and core injury, De’Von Achane and Zach Sieler are done for the year, and center Aaron Brewer, a second-team All-Pro last season, is in the concussion protocol. They score just 16.4 points a game.

But only one of their eight losses came by more than 14, a 35-13 loss at San Francisco in Week 2. The last five losses came by five, seven, five, 10 and two points. Last week, with Kyle McCord making his first NFL start, Miami lost 24-22 at Indianapolis and missed two field goals and an extra point. “That’s seven points,” Jeff Hafley said. McCord went 17-of-32 for 209 yards and ran for a score in his debut, and Ollie Gordon II ran for 76 yards on 20 carries. That’s a team still competing.

Buffalo’s defense is also getting thin. Cornerbacks Christian Benford (groin) and Dee Alford (concussion) left the Jets game, and linebacker Dorian Williams (calf) didn’t finish it. All three are questionable. The Bills have given up 256.3 passing yards a game, so a backup-heavy secondary can give McCord a few clean looks.

What could go wrong

Miami’s offense might not score enough to keep this inside two touchdowns and a field goal. It managed nine points against Detroit, and McCord now faces a defense that hasn’t allowed a touchdown in two straight games. Allen against a Dolphins defense missing Sieler, Zeek Biggers and Jordan Phillips up front could get ugly early. If Buffalo is up three scores by halftime, the backdoor needs a lot of help. The forecast also shows a good chance of rain, which could make it harder for a young quarterback to rally late.

Still, 16.5 points is a lot to lay with a team that has the Chiefs circled and has won most of its games by a touchdown or so. Give me the points.

Projected score: Bills 27, Dolphins 14

The Pick: Dolphins +16.5

Taking the biggest number on the board before the Thanksgiving showdown is a fun sweat, so bring some extra bankroll into Sunday. New players at MyBookie Sportsbook get a 100% REAL CASH bonus on a first deposit of $100 to $300 with promo code PREDICT100. That’s a FREE way to bet the Dolphins +16.5 and the rest of your Week 11 NFL picks.