Knicks at Raptors Rematch Prediction: Tuesday NBA Pick & Odds

by | Nov 17, 2026 | NBA Picks

New York Knicks and Toronto Raptors jerseys facing off at center court of Scotiabank Arena in Toronto for an NBA game

New York Knicks at Toronto Raptors
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
7:30 PM ET, Scotiabank Arena

The Knicks are 3.5-point favorites at most books (a few are dealing 2.5), and the total is 216.5. My play is the Raptors +3.5.

Forty-eight hours ago Toronto had this exact opponent down 13 in the fourth quarter and let it slip away. Now the same two teams walk back onto the same floor, and the market is asking us to lay more than a field goal with a Knicks team that needed overtime and a late Jalen Brunson triple to get out of the building. I’ll take the other side of that.

Sunday was closer than the final score lets on

New York won 112-108 in overtime, its 14th straight win over the Raptors. The Knicks shot just 13 of 36 from deep and went 1 for 7 from three in the third quarter. Toronto led 84-71 with under nine minutes left before Landry Shamet and Karl-Anthony Towns hit late threes, and Scottie Barnes forced overtime with a step-back three in the final seconds.

The game swung on the free-throw line. New York went 23 of 28; Toronto went 11 of 19. That is a gap of 12 points at the stripe in a four-point game. Toronto attacked the rim all night, outscoring the Knicks 52-36 in the paint and 17-9 on the break. Those parts of its game carry over to a rematch better than a cold night at the foul line does.

Barnes looked fine in his first game back from a strained left groin, scoring 30. Jamal Shead added 19 off the bench. Ja’Kobe Walter, Immanuel Quickley and RJ Barrett give Toronto enough creators to keep New York’s defense working.

The BEST 2026 Basketball Bonus: Deposit $100 to $1000 and get a 75% real cash bonus when you deposit using Bitcoin at Bovada Sportsbook!

The champs are good, but they are not a road machine yet

The defending champions are 7-6 and 3-3 away from Madison Square Garden. By my count from the box scores, New York gives up about 105 points per 100 possessions. That’s a strong defense, and it’s the main reason the Knicks are favored at all. The offense, though, scores about 111 per 100, almost exactly what Toronto does. Brunson (26.7 points a game) and Towns (21.6 points and 13.9 rebounds) carry a lot of it. Mikal Bridges is averaging only 6.8 points, and Josh Hart has gone scoreless in back-to-back games, so the help around the two stars has been thin.

Those numbers make New York a couple of points better than Toronto on a neutral floor. Give the Raptors their home court, and a fair line is closer to a pick’em than to Knicks -3.5.

The case against me. Toronto is 5-8, has lost four straight and seven of nine, and keeps blowing leads. AP noted the Raptors led by double digits in each of their last three losses. Kawhi Leonard (knee) and Nate Bittle (foot) are listed out, and Toronto is 3-8 without Leonard. Kevin McCullar Jr. is day-to-day with an illness. If Brunson gets hot early, the losing streak could get to the Raptors again. And a 14-game winning streak in a series doesn’t happen by accident.

Still, I’m not betting on the Raptors to finally win this series. I’m betting that a game decided by one late shot two nights ago shouldn’t be priced like a comfortable road win. If the number drops to 2.5, it’s still a small play; at +3.5, it’s a good one.

Projected score: Knicks 109, Raptors 107

The Pick: Raptors +3.5

Toronto keeps it close at the free-throw line this time, so bring some extra bankroll into Tuesday night. New players at MyBookie Sportsbook get a 100% REAL CASH bonus on a first deposit of $100 to $300 with promo code PREDICT100. That’s a FREE way to bet the Raptors +3.5 and the rest of your NBA picks.

75% Cash up to $750 (With BTC)

Bovada